I've been bothered by the current thesis most of the week and as I've reflected on it this weekend and am beginning to believe it's likely wrong. What has bothered me greatly is the volume story in the supposed head and shoulders pattern in the SPX. The reason I say that is that the volume on the left shoulder should be high; it wasn't. Furthermore, the volume on the head should be less than that of the left shoulder. Again not the case. This is not to mention that the supposed right shoulder was very weak and didn't come close to the level it should have attained.
So, if we probably don't have a H&S top, then what do we have? Looking at these charts it seems to be either a regular type correction in a long running bullish formation or the beginning of an intermediate to long term downtrend. Without the aid of a reversal pattern like the H&S top we simply have to keep an open mind about the intermediate term direction and look to other clues as they come about to what this may be.
In the shorter time frame, we still have a deeply oversold market. This is true of both my 10 and my 30 day oscillators. Next on my mind is time. Again, I refer you to the
previous sell offs that I've published before. In each of these three charts of recent large sell offs in the market, the reversal occurred between 7 to 11 days. In one of those three cases we spiked lower on day 6 and then reversed higher out of the rectangular area on day 11. On the other two occasions we held the rectangular area and broke higher on day 11 and day 7 respectively. Today we start day 6 in the rectangle. That suggests that it is rather likely that sometime this week we are likely to see a break out of this rectangle. Given how oversold the market is, if we head down, it's likely to be like the one case cited above and is likely not to carry down more than 10 to 15 SPX points or to the 1120 to 1125 SPX area.
Soemthing else to look for in any move, up or down, is that of speed. If we break to the downside, it's likely to be a fast move of which the majority of the move is most likely over within a day or two (unless exogenous events are driving it). If we break higher out of the rectangle, it's likely to take an extra day or two in order to really get moving (typical in cases where the break down has been severe). Given this, we can look to wait until we break higher out of the rectangle and hold into end of day before establishing significant long positions. On the short side, we should look to ride it out if we break lower with quick leveraged short trades at most.
ScenariosAnother advance to the 1162 area before the 1140 area - We saw the 200 day and the first look at 1160 propel us lower this past week. My guess is the first real look at 1162 or what would really be the second test of this area will likely be repelled again. Whether it's enough to get another push to bottom of the rectangle or even break it, I do not know. It does carry good risk/reward to short the next shot at that area though; especially early week.
A return to the 1140 area before the advance to 1162 area - If we continue down to the bottom of the rectangle before retesting the top that's a hard case to do much constructive. I am positioned about 30% long and do not wish to relinquish most of these longs. The next two levels of support are the 1128 area and then 1115. The only plan that makes sense in this situation is to incrementally build a short position around the levels we went out at on Friday knowing full well that we will add more heavily into the 1162 area if we do rise on the assumption that the second test fails. Another option is to stand pat and simply ride it out because we know from our oscillators that this market likely will not fall substantially from these levels (more the 3%).
On the NDX, the 1464 area is equivalent to the 1162 SPX area. Given that the NDX has show less relative strength, we likely should short the SPX if we short given it is much closer to resistance.
My Plan of Attack
- Continue to hold most of the existing longs
- Keep a watch list ready of longs to add
- Use the SPX or the e-mini to spread short but only if we rise to resistance and only then if we do it Monday or Tuesday at the latest
- Maintain a long bias and attempt to catch a ride with some leveraged vehicles, especially on a break above SPX 1164